Editor's Desk
From Fort Cass to Helene: Two Centuries of Washington Failing Appalachia
The federal government has been making decisions about these mountains since before Cleveland was a city. A look back at how those decisions have landed on the people who live here, from the Trail of Tears to the black lung cuts of 2025.
In 1835, the U.S. Army built a fort on the Hiwassee River at what is now Charleston, just north of Cleveland. It was called Fort Cass, and it served as the headquarters for the entire Cherokee removal.[1] It was also the largest of the emigrating depots, the camps where Cherokee families were held before being marched west.[2]
By the fall of 1838, about 9,000 Cherokee and 300 Creek people were held in stockades in Bradley County.[3] Red Clay, in the southern part of the county, had been the last eastern capital of the Cherokee Nation from 1832 until removal.[4]
This was the federal government's first big decision about the land we live on. It wasn't the last one made without asking the people who lived here.
The coal wars
By the early 1900s, coal companies controlled much of central Appalachia. Most miners lived in company towns.[5] In August 1921, about 10,000 armed miners marched in southern West Virginia to organize a union, and they ran into company-backed deputies at Blair Mountain.[6]
President Warren Harding sent 2,500 federal troops after the governor asked for them.[7] At least 16 men died in the fighting before the miners surrendered to the soldiers.[8] The union wasn't organized in southern West Virginia until 1935.[9]
The New Deal and the dams
In the 1930s, Washington came back with a different promise. The Tennessee Valley Authority was going to bring electricity and jobs to the region. Its first project, Norris Dam, relocated about 2,900 families and moved more than 5,000 graves.[10] Between 1933 and 1945, TVA displaced an estimated 82,000 people to build 16 dams.[11]
The agency created to lift up East Tennessee did not do much to help the families it moved resettle.[12] Many of them crowded onto the marginal land left in their counties, which made the poverty TVA was supposed to fix worse.[11]
The Great Smoky Mountains National Park was assembled around the same time. Families were often offered about half of what their farms were worth, and when they said no, the state used eminent domain. More than 5,000 people left their homes.[13]
The War on Poverty
On April 24, 1964, President Lyndon Johnson sat on Tom Fletcher's porch in Inez, Kentucky, to launch his War on Poverty.[14] Fletcher was a father of eight who had been out of work for most of the previous two years.[15] The next year, Congress created the Appalachian Regional Commission.[16]
A lot of good came out of that era, including Head Start, which still runs in Martin County today.[17] But a local woman told NPR on the program's 50th anniversary that it was more of a skirmish than a war.[18]
Disasters and inspectors
On Nov. 20, 1968, an explosion at the Consol No. 9 mine near Farmington, West Virginia, killed 78 miners. Their widows went to Washington to testify, and Congress passed the Federal Coal Mine Health and Safety Act in 1969.[19] That law created the free black lung screening program miners still depend on.[20]
Less than three years later, on Feb. 26, 1972, a coal waste dam owned by Pittston broke above Buffalo Creek in Logan County, West Virginia. Four days earlier, a federal mine inspector had called it satisfactory.[21] The flood killed 125 people and left about 4,000 homeless.[22] Pittston called it an act of God.[21]
Pills
In the 2000s, opioids poured into the same coal towns. A congressional investigation found that one pharmacy in Kermit, West Virginia, a town of about 400 people, got nearly 9 million opioid pills in two years.[23] Between 2007 and 2012, distributors shipped 780 million hydrocodone and oxycodone pills into West Virginia while 1,728 people there died of overdoses on those drugs.[24] The House committee's report blamed both the drug distributors and the DEA for not watching the flow of pills closely enough.[23]
Kingston
Closer to home, on Dec. 22, 2008, a dam holding coal ash at TVA's Kingston plant in Roane County collapsed and released more than a billion gallons of ash.[25] TVA, a federal utility, hired Jacobs Engineering to run the cleanup.[26]
Workers said they asked for dust masks and protective gear, and managers with both TVA and Jacobs refused and threatened to fire them.[27] A federal jury sided with the workers in 2018. By 2023, more than 50 of them had died and more than 150 were sick.[28]
Helene
Hurricane Helene hit in September 2024. Damage in western North Carolina alone was estimated at $60 billion, and some mountain counties spent more than their annual budgets on cleanup while they waited months for federal reimbursements.[29]
In Unicoi County, floodwaters surrounded the hospital in Erwin and patients had to be rescued from the roof.[30] A bridge repair on State Route 107 there took 18 months of review between local, state and federal officials before construction could begin.[31]
2025 and 2026
The black lung screening program that came out of Farmington lost most of its staff in federal layoffs in spring 2025, and the screenings stopped.[32] At the time, NIOSH estimated about 20% of coal miners in Central Appalachia had some form of black lung, the highest rate in 25 years.[33] A court ruling later restored part of the program, but most prevention researchers stayed furloughed.[34] A rule to lower silica dust exposure in coal mines, which the government estimated would prevent more than 1,000 deaths, is on hold while it's challenged in court.[35][36]
The White House proposed cutting ARC's budget by 93% for 2026. Congress put the money back.[37][38] The 2027 budget proposed cutting it again, by about 40%.[39]
In July 2025, Congress passed a budget bill with roughly $1 trillion in Medicaid cuts over 10 years.[40] The American Hospital Association estimated rural hospitals in Tennessee would lose $726 million in federal Medicaid funding over that time.[41]
The pattern
Not every federal decision has hurt the region. TVA brought power to farms that never had it. The Mine Act saved lives. ARC has paid for water lines and broadband in places no private company would go. Congress, including Republicans from Appalachian districts, has repeatedly protected ARC's funding.[42]
But the history runs in one direction often enough that people here notice. Land gets taken for someone else's plan. Safety rules show up after the funerals. Help arrives slowly, and cuts come first. In 2023, Appalachia had about 100 deaths from overdose, suicide and alcohol per 100,000 working-age residents, compared with 73 in the rest of the country.[43]
Fort Cass is gone now. Nothing is left of it.[44] The decisions made there, and in Washington for the 190 years since, are still with us.
Sources
- Wikipedia, "Fort Cass," https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fort_Cass ↩
- National Park Service, "Tennessee Trail of Tears" brochure, https://www.nps.gov/trte/planyourvisit/upload/Tennessee-Trail-of-Tears-brochure-508.pdf ↩
- Tennessee's Native American History (ArcGIS StoryMap), https://arcg.is/1OT5Gb0 ↩
- Research Online, "Points Along The Trail: Charleston, TN," https://researchonline.net/removal/point3.htm ↩
- Origins (Ohio State University), "The Battle of Blair Mountain," https://origins.osu.edu/read/battle-blair-mountain ↩
- Military.com, "The US Army Once Deployed Bombers and 2,500 Troops to Crush 10,000 Armed Coal Miners in West Virginia," https://365.military.com/daily-news/investigations-and-features/2026/01/09/us-army-once-deployed-bombers-and-2500-troops-crush-10000-armed-coal-miners-west-virginia.html ↩
- Origins (Ohio State University), "The Battle of Blair Mountain," https://origins.osu.edu/index.php/read/battle-blair-mountain ↩
- Associated Press, "AP Was There: Covering the Battle for Blair Mountain in 1921," https://abc17news.com/?p=652454 ↩
- "Battle of Blair Mountain 1921" (PDF), https://email.cainstructor.com/ Articles/History/Battle of Blair Mountain 1921.pdf ↩
- TNGenWeb, "History and Facts on Norris Dam," https://tngenweb.org/tva/NorrisDam/norris.php ↩
- Facing South, "Damming the Valley," https://www.facingsouth.org/1995/08/damming-valley ↩
- Loyola University Chicago, "Displacement" (Norris, TN eminent domain essay), https://healthlawonline.luc.edu/eminent-domain/siteessays/norristn/displacement ↩
- Smoky Mountains.org, Great Smoky Mountains National Park history, https://www.smokymountains.org/?p=19750 ↩
- Project MUSE, War on Poverty book excerpt, https://muse.jhu.edu/books/9780820341842/9780820341842-3.pdf ↩
- Huntington Herald-Dispatch (April 25, 1964), via West Virginia Archives and History, https://archive.wvculture.org/History/government/waronpoverty.html ↩
- WUKY, "Trump plan to slash ARC funding raises concerns across states," https://www.wuky.org/wuky-news/2025-07-21/trump-plan-to-slash-arc-funding-raises-concerns-across-states ↩
- NPR via WWNO, "Kentucky County That Gave War On Poverty A Face Still Struggles," https://www.wwno.org/npr-news/2014-01-08/kentucky-county-that-gave-war-on-poverty-a-face-still-struggles ↩
- NPR via KPBS, "Kentucky County That Gave War On Poverty A Face Still Struggles," https://www.kpbs.org/news/2014/01/07/kentucky-county-that-gave-war-on-poverty-a-face ↩
- U.S. Department of Labor, "Federal Coal Mine Health and Safety Act of 1969 paved way for major reforms," https://www.dol.gov/index.php/newsroom/releases/msha/msha20091230 ↩
- NPR, "Coal miners' health care hit hard in job cuts to CDC," https://www.npr.org/sections/shots-health-news/2025/04/09/nx-s1-5356067/niosh-cdc-coal-miner-black-lung-trump-doge ↩
- Wikipedia, "Buffalo Creek flood," https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Buffalo_Creek_flood ↩
- Society of Environmental Journalists, "40 years after Buffalo Creek, coal dam questions remain," https://www.sej.org/print/headlines/40-years-after-buffalo-creek-coal-dam-questions-remain ↩
- DTN Progressive Farmer, "House: Opioid Oversight Lax in Rural WV," https://www.dtnpf.com/agriculture/web/Ag/news/article/2018/12/19/committee-finds-pill-dumping-rural ↩
- Insurance Journal, congressional report on pill dumping in West Virginia, https://www.insurancejournal.com/news/southeast/2018/12/27/512925.htm ↩
- Associated Press via The News Courier, "Sick and dying workers demand help after cleaning coal ash," https://enewscourier.com/?p=244401 ↩
- LHSFNA, "Hundreds of Workers Sickened or Killed Following Coal Ash Cleanup," https://lhsfna.org/?p=12577 ↩
- Tennessee Lookout, "6th Circuit shoots down immunity for TVA coal ash spill contractor Jacobs Engineering," https://tennesseelookout.com/2022/05/18/6th-circuit-shoots-down-immunity-for-tva-coal-ash-spill-contractor-jacobs-engineering/ ↩
- Tennessee Lookout, "Jacobs Engineering settles Kingston coal ash case," https://tennesseelookout.com/2023/05/23/JACOBS-ENGINEERING-SETTLES-KINGSTON-COAL-ASH-CASE/ ↩
- WFAE, "Delayed Helene recovery money comes to North Carolina, FEMA funds run low," https://www.wfae.org/2026-02-27/delayed-helene-recovery-money-comes-to-north-carolina-fema-funds-run-low ↩
- NationGraph, "Unicoi County bridge on SR 107 getting repaired 18 months after Helene," https://news.nationgraph.com/articles/unicoi-county-bridge-on-sr-107-getting-repaired-18-months-after-helene ↩
- NationGraph, "Tennessee Mountain Roads Still Getting Hurricane Helene Repairs 18 Months Later," https://news.nationgraph.com/articles/tennessee-mountain-roads-still-getting-hurricane-helene-repairs-18-months-later ↩
- Environmental Health News, "Trump's cuts to miner health programs threaten black lung protections," https://www.ehn.org/trumps-cuts-to-miner-health-programs-threaten-black-lung-protections ↩
- Reuters via Yahoo News, "As Trump eyes coal revival, his job cuts hobble black lung protections for miners," https://www.yahoo.com/news/trump-eyes-coal-revival-job-100826202.html ↩
- Environmental Health News, "Trump administration halts key black lung research as miner deaths climb," https://www.ehn.org/trump-administration-halts-key-black-lung-research-as-miner-deaths-climb ↩
- Economic Policy Institute, "MSHA delays enforcement of silica rule for coal mines," https://www.epi.org/policywatch/msha-delays-enforcement-of-silica-rule-for-coal-mines/ ↩
- Mine Safety and Health Administration, Program Information Bulletin P26-01, https://www.msha.gov/sites/default/files/Directive%20%26%20Guidance/PIbs/P26-01.pdf ↩
- Appalachian Voices, "Facing a Funding Fight," https://appvoices.org/2025/07/24/facing-a-federal-funding-fight/ ↩
- NADO, "FY 2026 Funding Signed into Law: What's in the Bill for Regions," https://www.nado.org/fy-2026-funding-signed-into-law-whats-in-the-bill-for-regions/ ↩
- ReImagine Appalachia, statement on the FY2027 budget proposal, https://reimagineappalachia.org/?p=25491 ↩
- FOX6, "Rural hospitals prepare for financial hits, potential closures under GOP's $1 trillion Medicaid cut," https://www.fox6now.com/news/rural-hospitals-trump-medicaid-cuts ↩
- American Hospital Association, state-by-state estimates (PDF), https://www.aha.org/system/files/media/file/2025/06/Rural-Hospitals-at-Risk-Cuts-to-Medicaid-Would-Further-Threaten-Access.pdf ↩
- Rep. Riley Moore, "Congressman Riley M. Moore Delivers Major Wins for West Virginians in FY26," https://rileymoore.house.gov/media/press-releases/congressman-riley-m-moore-delivers-major-wins-west-virginians-fy26 ↩
- North Carolina Health News / Daily Yonder, deaths of despair in Appalachia, https://www.northcarolinahealthnews.org/?p=67771 ↩
- Tennessee History for Kids, "Bradley County," https://www.tnhistoryforkids.org/history/counties/bradley-county/ ↩